Home » Columns, Sharon Alva

Real Estate Roundup with Sharon Alva: Reality check

Submitted by on 1, February 19, 2010 – 5:55 am3 Comments

With the recession and the drop in prices, buyers feel (and rightfully so) that this is their chance to get a great deal on a house. But this being the Bay Area, I am often in the position of bursting bubbles. Because even a good deal may not be affordable.

This maybe obvious but bears repeating:

You cannot buy a 1,400-square-foot, three bedroom/two bath house with a yard, not on major street and preferably with a fantastic view, that is a cosmetic fixer, using an FHA loan, where the house has charm and great layout, in a safe neighborhood for under $300,000.

Not in Alameda. Not in Oakland, and not in Berkeley. Not even in San Leandro (in case you thought that would be a good fallback position). Now go define safe neighborhood! It’s a very personal choice. But that’s the challenge clients come to me with every day.

Something’s gotta give. Is it neighborhood? Maybe a condo and not a house? Maybe it’s got to be an itty bitty house first time around. Maybe it has big structural issues and the buyers will have to forgo any luxuries for the next few years in order to fix it up. Maybe two of these factors.

I encourage buyers to look at things in their price range. If you don’t like what you see, look at spending more. If that’s not possible, not desirable, or neither affordable nor desirable, than change your parameters. Asking for the same parameters in the same price range even after repeated failure is like banging your head in the wall.

I do feel your pain. Prices remain high in the Bay Area. Thinking that asking for a house in a less coveted neighborhood in Oakland or Alameda is the way out may not be satisfying, since prices are relatively high even in those areas. The compromise a buyer has to make may be bigger, and more painful, than anticipated.

The lower prices set by those selling homes in short sale situation or foreclosures seems like it is mocking the buyer who is out there looking for a bargain. Beneath every super-low price are multiple offers. The buyer may not even see that a property has an accepted offer at a much higher price than that showing in their online search because the short sale process is long, and it looks like the property is still active when in fact 12 offers have been received and the bank is slowly going through its process with a chosen offer.

Have your agent look at homes sold in your chosen neighborhood. Those are the only true indication of what the market price really is, and your agent, who is out there every day, knows the selling-value of properties in the area where you are searching.

I don’t want to dishearten anyone, since I think this is a phenomenal time to buy and good deals are out there to be had. But the good deals are relative to the area we live in. And the future value of the purchased property will reflect that same reality. You, me and the folks competing with you for that great deal all want to be here and nowhere else. The Bay Area, after all, is Nirvana – with a price to match.

Sharon Alva is a real estate agent with Alain Pinel, living in Alameda. While Sharon has been known to perform real-estate miracles, she has not been able to find a 1,400-square-foot, three bedroom/two bath house with a yard, not on major street and preferably with a fantastic view, that is a cosmetic fixer, using an FHA loan, where the house has charm and great layout, in a safe neighborhood for under $300,000. You can reach her at sharon@alvaproperties.com.


  • Dave K says:

    Nice article Sharon, and I want to point out an option for buyers that you left out.

    Growing in popularity is the East Bay Co-Housing organization. ( http://www.ebcoho.org ) This is for a good reason – Groups of people can often buy or design/build there are many ways in which co-housing and housing cooperatives make ownership more feasible. I even saw some openings for a co-op condo in Berkeley at the incredible price of $2600 – buy-in and $620/mo carrying charge. Granted this was for a 522 sf 1 bedroom unit but what a price!

    What makes these kinds of affordability is that the 10 unit complex was acquired as a Land Trust deal decades ago. Anybody who thinks public land trusts don’t help should study the issue.
    G ranted there are differences between Co-ops, and Co-Housing.

    In this instance the Land Trust worked with HUD and Berkeley’s Housing Authority to form the limited equity housing co-op. Values increase by only 2%/year, that is why it is now so affordable. In the Bay Area there are hundreds of co-housing and co-ops that are operating as communities. Many houses, even in Alameda can easily be converted to these options.

  • Barbara M says:

    Yes co-housing is an interesting option but can’t happen in Alameda as we think “measure A” will keep our little utopia free of riff-raff, hippies and TRAFFIC!

  • Martin says:

    Alameda is a lovely place to live. Nice people, climate, schools…
    There is a very nasty real estate blog called Knifecatchers that insists on trashing various houses that come up for sale. Very sad that such a negative person exists. They won’t even allow comments on their website anymore because
    when comments were allowed they were all negative.

Leave a comment!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.